We have done our research!
The custom made wooden windows which were built as early as 1890, were made with old-growth wood. These windows last longer than vinyl or aluminum windows. Vinyl window frames will start to crack due to the exposure to the elements, aluminum frames will eventually corrode.
The warranty on real high-end vinyl or aluminum windows is 20-25 years. The original wooden windows would have had a 124 year warranty in 1890.
Are these wooden windows attractive in their current condition?
Nope. Let’s agree that peeling paint and dirty glass will not win any Better Homes and Garden awards. Here are some articles and videos on our plan to restore these windows.
Discussion on old windows versus new windows
The current windows will not degrade, dissolve, or disappear. Which would be wiser, keeping these windows in our vacation home, or keeping them in the landfill?